How To Get Dogs To Behave In The Car
Training Dogs To Behave While Riding In The Car
Up until recently, I did not think we had a problem with any of our dogs riding in cars! We actually didn't to any noticeable extent until the last 5 or 6 months. However, in retrospect on thinking about it, I suspect it was there all along but for some reason it did not come to the forefront until we lost our other dog. Then it became crystal clear that yes indeed we had a problem that I needed to go in search of a solution for - and pronto!
GETTING DOGS TO BEHAVE IN THE CAR
Let me explain - we have malamutes and sometimes in their inherent stubbornness it can be a little belatedly that you realize 'Houston, we have a problem'. Denaya is our older malamute and until May of this year, we had another malamute who was a male and was a few years older than Denaya. Let me preface all of this with the fact that this breed of dogs is meant to go - they love riding in cars because that means that they get to do that - GO! I had noticed that whenever we loaded them up to go somewhere when there were the 2 of them that they did the malamute 'yodel' or 'singing' as I like to think of it - but it was never THAT BAD!
Well, since Kodi died, it got THAT BAD! Gradually over the period of several months now, Denaya began not yodeling, not malamute singing, but what I like to refer to as Howler Monkey Screaming - in the back of the SUV. No matter what we tried, it was to no avail and it just kept getting worse instead of better.
At first, we thought it was some kind of separation anxiety from Kodi (it may very well be but unfortunately, she's not talking about her issues). It was never though as if she didn't want to go or balked at the going! She was first out of the blocks TO GO. We would leash her up and get her outside to the car where she would proceed to launch herself into the back like the athletic dog that she is. She would start a bit of whining (low-key) while we loaded up Griffin our puppy after we brought him home - but she did that even before we had Griff so could really not pinpoint any correlation there - as in 'I'm so jealous'.
As soon as we started to back out of the driveway, it would start. No matter if we went around the block or we went on a 4-hour jaunt with lots of stops, there was no stopping her. This was not the little bit of whining that one could ignore either or drown out by turning on the radio. This was the mother of all screeching - the over the top ear-splitting octaves that seriously made me think of asking Bob to pull over more than once and throw 'mama from the train'. But how to fix this?
Now that she had begun this terrible habit, we tried everything we could think of - I researched on the Internet; I read and reread dog books. Basically what I came up were a few tricks which I will mention below but one salient feature stood out from all my research - if you could not break this habit, you might as well forget it because it was going to become a permanent fixture of this dog's personality and the only way to treat it would be with sedatives. You have to be kidding me I was thinking to myself. For a shopping day to Bend, I will need to drug the dog up every time? Ridiculous!
The problem obviously did not seem to be in the actual GOING since she loves that. The problem began once the motor started or we started moving. She was a rescued/abused dog so I have no way of knowing if something triggered this response or something brought it to a head when Kodi died and left her behind. In truth, she has always seemed well-adjusted enough on her own about many things and she was always the alpha - so again not making sense! However, the reason WHY suddenly did not seem to be so important but a way to make it STOP imperative!
Things I Tried
From my research and gathering all kinds of helpful hints, I tried all of these things - I might add to NO avail - in fact I believe the screeching grew in volume!
- Giving the dog a chew toy to allow her to take her anxiety out on the bone or toy
- Giving her a chewy treat to keep her occupied eating that
- Putting her in her own crate to help her feel more secure
- Speaking to her in a calming way
- Turning the radio on
- Turning the radio on REALLY LOUD
- Opening windows
- Telling her 'no' in a very authoritative voice
- Stopping to see if she had to go to the bathroom - about 1000 times - sometimes she did but it was never a consistent indicator
- Howling along with her - NO I DID NOT!
- Resolving to never in my lifetime be in a car with her again - again, no I did not!
The most interesting part here is that little Griffin did not latch onto this behavior as most malamutes I think would and start yodeling his own tune! He would just lay in his crate and be completely quiet chewing on his toys or bone. He is totally at home riding in a car and never is happier than when he is going with us somewhere - though so was Naya until something triggered this unsettling behavior in her.
Of particular interest though is the fact that when the car is parked while we run in somewhere and we get out, instant quiet. I deduce from this that she is no longer moving so I suppose she is now no longer stressed. Also of note, wherever we go outside the car, there is no stress. She is totally at ease with us and doing things in new environments or old. So it has to be the car or the riding!
Why Don't You Just Leave the Dog Home?
Interesting point - as a matter of fact, many of our friends having RIDDEN with the beast had asked us this very same question! I advised them it might be a good idea in the future for them to drive their own car because 'quit' just doesn't happen to be in my vocabulary. Also drugging a dog does not seem to be an appropriate response to fixing a problem. I just wanted to get to the bottom of it and somehow make it work for everyone but mostly Denaya.
I started to think back a bit and I do remember on the wild ride from Eastern Washington to Western Washington after we had picked her up from the malamute rescue group that she had behaved a little erratically in the car. She was in the back of our Subaru and we did not have a gate up at the time. It became quickly evident that she was not content to be back there for any reason or any time. She proceeded to very gingerly crawl over a loaded-to-the-brim car to get to the backseat so she could be close to us. I vaguely remembered as well that there was an element of panic that set in when all the windows were rolled up.
I then started to remember my almost fatal drive from Western Washington to Central Oregon when we moved. I had been given the daunting responsibility of traveling with TWO malamutes in the Subaru while my friend drove behind me. The car would not accommodate a crate to fit either of the dogs so Kodi was in the back with a gate and Denaya was riding in the backseat in an open HALF crate. All was well until again, I somehow forgot about the windows and in the heat, rolled up all the windows in order to turn the air conditioner on.
On the top of Mt. Hood, going 55 or so, I looked in the rearview mirror to meet 2 malamute eyes boring through me - she was not only UP but she was coming into the front seat whether I liked it or not. How I ended up not driving into oncoming traffic while I fought the dog back with my ELBOW while driving one-handed on the curves is beyond me! I have never seen such panic - in her or in me! I think I had a minor stroke during that little episode and had to pull to the side of the road and burst into tears to get myself back up to the task of driving on! My girlfriend was not in much better shape! I did remember though that the dog had a problem with the windows rolled up (a little belatedly) and when I made sure she had air the rest of the trip, she was okay. I also decided right there and then - never again - no loose dogs (especially malamute) in a car that I'm in!
Tips For Traveling With Dogs
Except for the howler monkey singing, I have found that these other things have worked really well for us!
- Always interrupt car travel for breaks to get the dogs out and walk them around - it is also good for the driver. At most, go an hour and stop and have a lope around, let them potty and have a drink of water - the MOST a dog should travel at a time is recommended at 4 hours but think that might be pushing it for large or active dogs
- Crating a dog is safer, especially if the dog is smaller. It also protects the dog more in the case of an accident. It also obviously prevents said dog from trying to get into the front seat of your car and take over the driving. I would never advise traveling in a car alone with ANY loose dog - at the very minimum, a gate in back should separate them from you
- Make sure you bring water, treats, food and potty bags. Make sure your dog has a collar, tags and leash. In the odd event that your dog gets loose somewhere foreign, you want that collar and tag on him or her
- If your dog displays anxiety about traveling from the outset, start slow and take small trips. Reward the dog for quiet behavior and good behavior in the car
- Dog drink bottles attached to crates are great - if the dog will not drink from them, apply a dab of honey and they will figure it out! Always make sure you give the dog plenty of water
- Dogs are not recommended to be left in cars for great lengths of time if the temperature is over 60 degrees outside - you should leave the windows down on all sides a few inches to allow airflow but again, if the temp is over 60, the inside car temperature escalates rapidly. If we are shopping in the summer - or even in the winter - usually one of us walks the dogs and the other shops and we trade off. We also sit outside and eat weather permitting with our dogs rather than leave them in the car
- For small dogs, a harness or seat belt is advised in case of sudden braking. We have friends who had a chihuahua in the back seat and when there was an accident, he ended up getting hurt simply because he was thrown all over the car
- Place chew toys or favorite toys inside crates or in the back of the car with the gate if the dog appears more content with them
- Be aware that some dogs have a hard time with motion sickness and make sure you do not feed him or her for several hours before traveling if that is a problem
How I Fixed The Problem
After many mutterings and grumblings to everyone I knew about this ongoing dilemma with Denaya and the howler monkey chorus that was becoming worse by the day, I happened to mention this to my mother. I was telling her how badly I felt because we were beginning to lean towards leaving her at home each and every time when we thought about what we would have to face IF we put her in the car! As much as we love the dog, it was just becoming entirely too much on the nerves not to mention the ears to have to deal with this over and over.
The next time I talked to her (my mother, not Denaya), she said she had gone into the pet store herself to get food for her dog and had decided to just ask one of the sales people about it. The girl that helped her said something about it being 'normal' for malamutes to sing - whereupon my mom decided to let her know that this was way beyond 'normal' and that I was quickly getting to the end of my tether on it because I could not solve the mystery. The gal was so sweet and led my mom to a bunch of books, etc. and they poured over these training books to see if they could also come up with a solution I could use! Now I had the whole pet force out looking for answers.
Well, my mom called me afterwards and explained where she had gone and didn't have too much to report but the gal had made one suggestion; maybe I should try it. She suggested I should take a little squirt bottle with me in the car and if she started the howling, just to give her a little squirt and see if it wouldn't curtail the behavior. She suggested citrus (lots of dog trainers use this as a deterrent for behaviors in class) but my mom and I both agreed that probably would not be a great idea spraying citrus all over the car and the dog.
Being the wonderful husband that he is, when I asked Bob if I could possibly try this new technique and could he stand it for an hour drive, he agreed to give it a go. The next shopping day we needed to head out, we loaded up the dogs and had not even made it out of the driveway before she was cranking it up a notch. I very calmly gave her a shot from the spray bottle and said 'no' - dead silence. A few minutes later, there was another attempt at hitting a high 'C' - the squirt and a 'no' - and silence. I wanted to shout out 'you have to be KIDDING me - this is all it took?' but sometimes you just have to go with what you get. I can't believe it could have been THAT simple!
Weeks later, I can testify that it is still working! I was worried at first that it was a flash in the pan - she was just pondering this over for a while and she was going to get back at me big time later on and increase the decibels even more - but it has proven effective EVERY time. She is not a water dog per se and not sure if it is the water or just the 'insult' of being squirted with a small stream of water but she turns it off instantly.
She in fact does not even screech or shriek anymore - she just kind of starts to mutter and grumble to herself (I think she is calling me malamute swear words under her breath). She never goes into the full vibrato of her routine. She settles down and she may pant a bit, but our rides now are QUIET and tolerable. I can just imagine little Griffin in his crate thinking 'good GRIEF - it's about time - maybe now I can get some sleep!' I also think that part of it is the idea that the water is coming from 'somewhere' and not from me - the environment is scolding her for her behavior but I could be all wrong on that score! All I care about is the quiet and knowing I can again take her with us and not have it turn into a headache in the making.
By the way, thanks to my mom for going that extra mile and ferreting out the information! In all my readings, I had never come across something as simple as using a squirt bottle in the car. I don't think it would have done me much good on the mountain though as I was missing a third hand!