report

Best Family Watchdog

The Rottie is the family watch dog that does not sleep.
The Rottie is the family watch dog that does not sleep. | Source

The Best Family Watchdog

The best family watch dog is the Rottweiler.

Stating that something is the best is never easy but it is clear in this case that the Rottweiler is the best watchdog for your family. I can state this with no bias since I do not have a Rottie protecting me. I own a Pit Bull cross and she is fine since she looks the part of a guard dog and also has a deep bark to alert me if anyone happens to walk by on the beach. Since she is great with kids, and I have known plenty of the “Nanny dogs” that are good with children, it would be easy for me to recommend the Pit Bull as the best guard dog. Unfortunately, it would not be true. Well trained and socialized Rottweilers perceive the difference between friend and foe and make excellent family watch dogs.

So why do Rottweilers get such bad press when the authors of “Top ten guard dogs” make their lists? They are not an easy breed for some owners to handle. They are powerful and have the ability to do damage. (Isn´t that what people are looking for in a guard dog?) Like all dogs they can be aggressive if not properly socialized and an aggressive dog is not a good family watch dog.

A 2008 study in the Journal of Applied Animal Behaviour showed that Rottweilers were only average among the breeds that bit their owners but were shown to be more aggressive to strangers.

This is the best family watchdog.
This is the best family watchdog. | Source

Rotties Are Perfect For The Job

The Rottweiler is the best family watch dog.
The Rottweiler is the best family watch dog. | Source

Besides being such a good watch dog, the Rottie is also a great guard dog. Let’s discuss the Rottweilers function as a guard dog. He is almost perfect for the task.

1. He is large (a male is over 100 pounds) and so he intimidates anyone lurking around your property.

2. He is black, a color that most people, especially thieves, find scary. Do you think color does not matter? Why do security police wear black and milkmen wear white? Would you be nervous if your protest march met a line of security forces all in white?

3. He has a deep growl, a fierce bark, and, most importantly of all, he has a large head. The dog looks like a guard.


I´ve seen some breeds like the Great Pyrenees recommended as guard dogs. Animal Planet even recommends the Rough Collie and the Bernese Mountain Dog. Where I live a thief would not be bothered by a guard dog like a Great Pyrenees or even a Komondor but would never try to pass by a Rottie. Just being able to growl and bark does not qualify a dog as the best.

A “Beware of Rottweiler” sign will usually work.

Rotties As A Family Dog

They are great watchdogs, excellent guards, but we also need to look at his qualifications as a family dog.

1. Socialized Rottweilers are as protective with their human charges as they would be with the cows and sheep they used to protect.

2. Rotties are an easy to care for family dog. Their coats are short and do not require a lot of brushing. They can be prone to obesity so if there are a lot of children in the house slipping the dog treats the regular diet needs to be adjusted, and of course they need to be exercised a lot more. Rottweilers need to be screened for hip dysplasia but that is not uncommon is the big breeds.

3. The biggest disadvantage with Rottweilers is their short life span. It is as long as other large breeds (9 or 10 years) but still less than what the family will hope for.

Yes, there have been several cases of Rottweilers biting (and even killing) children but in all of these cases the dogs were poorly socialized, abused, and maintained in terrible conditions. If you are going to maintain your dog in that condition, there is no such thing as a good breed out there.

A Rottweiler  with her family.
A Rottweiler with her family. | Source

Should I Find A Rottweiler?

Some countries have laws banning Rottweilers. If you are in the US, be sure to check with your insurance agent before choosing and bringing home your new dog. You might find out that your insurance company will raise your rates or even refuse to insure you if you choose to have a Rottie. They usually have a biased list based on the most inflammatory news story so you may need to choose a dog that has not yet made the evening news.

If you do decide to find a Rottweiler to serve as your family watch dog be sure to do a lot of reading and investigating. You might find a breed rescue in your area, your local animal shelter may have several Rottweilers to adopt, or a neighbor might not be able to keep an adult Rottie for many reasons (moving, no insurance, etc.) There are articles to read on puppies, guides to Rottweilers, and you can find good breeders in your area to help you find the best dog suited for your family.

Get your family guard dog soon.

Comments 17 comments

dharam 19 months ago

Own a rottweiler and forget theives, anti social elements, , tresspasers, any strangers .forget about children safety in home, rott will handle it.in india I only close the door from outside not locked it for 5-6 hour so there is nobody has the courage to open the door even the neighbors.the best dog breed I seen ever, best with your children, like second mom or father. Nobody ever can dare to touch your childrens.also good with others your friends your children's friends, be.......................................................st breed gift to humans.


livewirez profile image

livewirez 3 years ago from Pearl of the Orient Sea

Dogs are man's best friend. We had a dog in our house and it serve as our guard.


DrMark1961 profile image

DrMark1961 3 years ago from The Beach of Brazil Author

Thanks for the comment, Sara. George sounds like he was great.


Sarra Garrett 3 years ago

Voted up and awesome. I love the Rotti and raising my pups was an experience I'll never forget. They are smart and loving dogs. My male was named George, he weighed 130 lbs and was a huge lap dog. lol. Yes, my pups were all house trained at 8 weeks. All it takes is lots of love, patients, encouragement and praise.


Eiddwen profile image

Eiddwen 4 years ago from Wales

What a great hub and such wonderful dogs I award this one my special up up and away!!!

Enjoy your weekend.

Eddy.


alexadry profile image

alexadry 4 years ago from USA

Oops forgot to vote up, just did it now. They are also great dogs for the fact that they do not waste their time barking for subtle things unless you show them what is relevant and worthy for it. And it is in their standard to have a "wait and see" attitude about things which makes them ideal for the watch-dog role.


DrMark1961 profile image

DrMark1961 4 years ago from The Beach of Brazil Author

They sound like lucky dogs! As you have noticed, I do not think this breed even needs special watch dog training as they already look the part. That makes a big difference.

Thanks for coming by and commenting!


alexadry profile image

alexadry 4 years ago from USA

Dr Mark, I am owned by two Rottweilers and I would never own any other breed. While they are very friendly, they do look intimidating to anyone who does not know them. When I walk them together people walk the other way but they do not know they are wagging their tails in hopes of attention. I always discouraged them to take territoriality seriously, since we do not have a fence in the front yard and people, animals and cars are always passing by so I can relax when they are sent out to potty. People say I have two wasted guard dogs, but they do not know that when we are not home, they take over protecting the house. More than guard dogs, (too much responsibility) I see them better used as watch dogs. Indeed, they are the best to alert us of anything unusual. My male, Kaiser has even learned (on his own) to alert my hubby when coffee is ready or when the water is spilling out when I am cooking or something is sizzling and about to burn (I have to write a hub about him, he is such a special boy). He saved tons of lasagna trays from burning! My female alerts me of any nasty bug that made itself in the house with the most disgusted whine. They both tell us if somebody is knocking on the door; no aggressive barking, just walking towards us whining and directing us towards the door. I feel blessed living with them, and look forward to adding another one when I move and space permits.


DrMark1961 profile image

DrMark1961 4 years ago from The Beach of Brazil Author

Thanks for coming by. Yes, I think a lot of it has to do with the face also, not just the color. One of the fiercest dogs I have seen is the Caucasian Mountain Dog, but they have a "huggable" face, so their job would be that much harder.


Suhail and my dog profile image

Suhail and my dog 4 years ago from Mississauga, ON

I agree with the black colour theory to some extent. I have a Kuvasz, who is all white in colour. People in the neighbourhood don't consider him to be intimidating and children rush over to pat him. Kuvaszok are livestock guardian dogs and white colour was encouraged to differentiate them from marauding wolves. They are fierce protector of land and property, but this white colur also gives them a less intimidating disposition although an average Kuvasz is 28" at his withers and weighs around 110 -125 Lbs.

If you ask me, it is brachiocephalic breeds like Rotties, Cane Corsos, dogo argentinos, presa canarios, fila brasilieros, pitbulls, Tosa Inus, Boerbols, etc. who look more intimidating. Therefore, fear is more from the way body is built rather than the colour. A black Saluki for example, will never look intimidating, but a white dogo argentino will.

This is an excellent hub. I am glad I ran into it :-)


DrMark1961 profile image

DrMark1961 4 years ago from The Beach of Brazil Author

Thanks for coming by wetnosedogs. Always good to see your comments.

DIFH, I think it is because most people are around smaller "vira latas" (trashcan dogs) and don't respect medium size. The Pit Bull is an exception because the media reports every single dog bite, anywhere in the country. Also, a dog can be 7/8 Labrador and 1/8 Pit but the media will report "Today a Pit Bull attacked a man". Even if the dog is 1/8 Rottie, they still report the bite as "Pit Bull".


DoItForHer 4 years ago

Interesting how you say thieves don't respect a smaller dog. Perhaps that is because where you are at, the people have more dog sense. Here I cannot remember a time outside of an obedience class that someone wasn't afraid of a dog of any size.

I'm a rather narrow dude and people think of me as weak. While it is true that I'm not particularly strong, I'm not a pansy. No matter if I beat up a person nearly twice my size, the other guy will always be more intimidating and will be taken more seriously.

I would rather stop a threat by appearance than having to physically stop it. Couple that with competent behavior and Rotties are hard to beat.

Another advantage is how Rotties use their drool to make the bad guy slip and fall. lol


wetnosedogs profile image

wetnosedogs 4 years ago from Alabama

Wonderful hub on a wonderful dog.

Sharing this. Those dogs need a boost of understanding.


DrMark1961 profile image

DrMark1961 4 years ago from The Beach of Brazil Author

I would agree on the training but the problem with the 45 pound type is that the thieves just don't respect a breed that small. Around here the theives would just laugh and throw something at the dog.

Personally I would choose the Cané Corso over a Dobie because the Dobie just does not have any weight to throw around. I think they do not intimidate in the same way.

Good point about the popularity.


DoItForHer 4 years ago

Make sure to find a competent breeder; Rotties have suffered from their popularity.

Size is a consideration. Size alone can thwart a threat, but that size will do no good if the owners tend to leave the dog home because it is too inconvenient to transport. But what 45 pound breed has the characteristics of a Rottie? Non that I know of. Some breeds come close like a Blue Heeler.

I can train the bajeebers out of a dog, but a dog that has a limited inherent understanding of proper guarding and bravery can respond only so much to training.

Not every dog is born a gladiator like not every human is born to be a firefighter. Training goes a loooong way, but it isn't everything.

Curious how you would compare the Dobie?


DrMark1961 profile image

DrMark1961 4 years ago from The Beach of Brazil Author

Thanks for the great comment. I really hope families will consider this great misunderstood dog.


midget38 profile image

midget38 4 years ago from Singapore

Great recommendation, Mark! I think Rotties are the most misunderstood doggies we know. Lots of dogs are aggressive when socialized the wrong way. Came across a Yorkshire who was so badly beaten up that she treated anyone who came near as a potential enemy... No one could touch her. She bit everyone without reason! Thanks for sharing!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    © 2012 DrMark1961

    More by this Author


    DrMark1961 profile image

    DrMark1961567 Followers
    286 Articles

    Dr Mark is a veterinarian in Brazil. He also trains dogs, mostly large breeds and dogs suffering from aggression problems.



    Click to Rate This Article

    Menu

    Resources