Why Is My Dog Carrying a Toy in His Mouth and Whining?

Why Do Some Dogs Whine While Carrying Toys?

A dog typically does one of two things with his favorite toy: carry it to his favorite spots to relax with and gnaw on or pace restlessly with the toys in his mouth, whining endlessly.

If your dog does that latter, you're probably wondering what gives. There are several explanations for such a behavior, but one thing is sure: He is definitively not complaining for want of a better toy!

Possible Explanations

Because dogs cannot talk, we can ultimately only make assumptions for their behavior. The age, gender, and breed of the dog may be factors to keep in mind when looking at specific dog behaviors.

For instance, if the behavior is carried out by an unspayed female, it may be that she is exhibiting the first signs of a false pregnancy. A false pregnancy takes place after a dog has gone through heat, but she did not mate/her eggs were not fertilized. A female in false pregnancy may therefore engage in mothering behaviors such as carrying toys around as if they were her pups. She may therefore form an emotional attachment to her toys and whine as she carries them around looking for a place to nest.

However, males, spayed females, and females not actively undergoing a false pregnancy may also carry toys and whine but for quite different behaviors. For instance:

  • A perception of the toy as high-value:Some dogs, when given high-value items such as bones, will whine and walk around for some time, almost as if looking for a safe place to bury it. Then they eventually calm down and decide to chew on or play with it. Certain breeds, especially those bred to hunt, see squeaky toys as high-value items. Labs and Goldens for instance, were bred to retrieve waterfowl, so a squeaky toy making a sound that mimics a downed bird may cause excitement.
  • An instinct to bury the toy: If your dog does not normally hide stuff, it could be that he instinctively knows that there is something he is supposed to do with his treasured toy, but doesn't know what (especially if he has never seen another dog bury his treasures).
  • Excitement: Some dogs, on the other hand, seem to be so excited about having a new toy they do not know how to express themselves, and this generates whining sessions.
  • A desire to play: It could be the dog wants the owner to play with the toy with him, and whining is his way to express that desire. For example, if you've taught your dog to play fetch, he may come with his toy in his mouth requesting a session. If you do not pay attention, he may whine. If the whining gets your attention and you toss the ball, then the whining is reinforced and will likely be repeated every time the dog wants to play. However, this is different behavior than carrying a toy aimlessly around. The dog actively seeking a play session.

As long as your dog does not become protective of the toy, whining is quite an innocent behavior. But it can get annoying, especially if your dog notices it flags your attention. If it bothers you, you can try to invest in toys that are more interactive such as Kongs. You can fill Kongs with goodies, which encourages the dog to actively seek out its contents. This leads to the dog laying down and working on it, rather than carrying it around aimlessly. A win-win situation for all!

More by this Author

Comments 25 comments

alexadry profile image

alexadry 4 weeks ago from USA Author

Amy B, Aww.. so cute, looks like you did what your dog was just hoping for, gotta love 'em!

Amy B. 6 weeks ago

Thank so much for this post. My daughter`s new puppy chewy got a new squeaky toy from his bark box and was whining non stop with it in his mouth. We tried everything. I read this post and learned he wanted to bury it, so we put a large blanket in the floor and he instantly hid his new treasure in the blanket and is very happy now!

alexadry profile image

alexadry 2 months ago from USA Author

Bridget, please seek the help of a good trainer using positive training methods!

bridget 2 months ago

my jack russell goes after people when they approach him . also when they try to leave the house he goes after them. he will bite them i dont no what to do.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 4 months ago from USA Author

Hello Kathy, it depends on why your dog is carrying a toy and whining in the first place. Is your dog spayed or not?

Kathy 4 months ago

How long does this last my dog has been whining and carrying her toy puppy around with her

alexadry profile image

alexadry 7 months ago from USA Author

It could be a false pregnancy or something else going on. A vet check could be helpful to rule out anything physical going on. Try to exercise her more and keep her mentally stimulated.

Addison 8 months ago

My Female husky was recently spayed at a year old. She had just finished her second heat, and we waited the recommended time after heat before getting her spayed. Now she is whining and restlessly carrying around a rubber lizard toy. She checks on it every few hours and seems really concerned about it and sometime she brings it to me. Could this be false pregnancy? even though she was recently spayed?

Edu 8 months ago

My beagle (9 months) does that but in a more funny/diff way. He grabs his bone AND a toy and THEN he starts all this eternal crying and walking. In most times he is looking for a place to bury it (and it tends to be our couch with a couple of blankets so he thinks it's actually being buried).

Some other times he just keeps looking at me and crying with his mouth full of stuff (toy, bone... sometimes 2 toys). I guess he wants attention :)

alexadry profile image

alexadry 10 months ago from USA Author

Well, we have domesticated our dogs and put them in an artificial environment in our homes, those instincts are always alive and our homes do not offer the same burying spots as nature intended to, so it's not surprising if dogs are often frustrated or in conflict. Thanks for sharing your story!

alexadry profile image

alexadry 2 years ago from USA Author

Good question! Generally, it's best to let it run its course. Taking the stuffed animal away will not solve the underlying problem. Your dog may resource guard it and may get defensive or may be looking for a "substitute." and if a substitute cannot be found, your dog may pace, whine etc. A better option may be to walk your dog or try engage her with some activities such as extracting food from a stuffed Kong.

tom 2 years ago

My chihuahua is experiencing a false pregnancy. It's kind of funny but is getting annoying. Should we take her you away or will it stress her out more?

Andrew 2 years ago

We've had our adopted Cocker Spaniel mix for about a week and we've found that she whines when we give her a toy that squeaks or makes a crinkle noise. She'll take those toys to her "den" under a side table in our living room (a spot she picked out pretty quick as a 'safe' place). She doesn't really like playing with the noisy toys, just brings them to her den. She's about 5 years old but was only recently spayed. I wondered if some maternal instincts were making her treat them like puppies she may have had before we adopted her.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 2 years ago from USA Author

Hello Maegan, have you figured out a potential cause for your dog carrying a toy in her mouth and whining?

Meagan 2 years ago

Thank you so much for this information. I was becoming increasingly concerned- as my dog has carried out this behavior for several days now.

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Is she intact? If so, has she been in heat recently-like a month or two ago? this sounds like nesting behavior in a dog with a false pregnancy.

april 3 years ago

my girl been cry for a week she only eats half her food ,cry for every small little thing and takes her toy ever this is the second time thing this happens but why?

alexadry profile image

alexadry 3 years ago from USA Author

Thanks for the thumbs up! My girl has to add the whining on top of it, but it's fortunately short-lived:)

Solaras profile image

Solaras 3 years ago

Thumbs Up and Interesting. I have a boy that will not great me when I come home unless he has a toy in his mouth. If he sees me pulling up in the driveway, he runs to get a toy for the greeting. No whining though thank goodness!

Emily 4 years ago

My doberman does this all the time

D. 4 years ago

My German Shepherd does this. At least now we'll finally have a reasoning behind it.

C. 4 years ago

Very interesting. Thank you for the information. My dog doesn't whine - he just wanders around until he finds a place to bury something. Haa. At times he tries to bury his food and he gets it all over the floor. If he wants to play, he goes and gets his ball and then stands and looks at me. It's my friends dog that wanders around with a toy and she whines. So, I will give her your information.

tlpoague profile image

tlpoague 4 years ago from USA

My doesn't wine, but instead, drops her toy by our feet. If we ignore her, she will tap our leg with her paw. If this still doesn't bring the attention she wants, she will sneeze on our feet or place her paws on the arms of our computer chair. This is her way of showing us she is ready to play, eat, or go outside. I sometimes find the behavior annoying when I am busy, but most of the time laugh at how she is communicating. It would be nice if they could talk, I would love to hear what they were thinking.

Millionaire Tips profile image

Millionaire Tips 4 years ago from USA

While I have figured out the basic language of my dog - when he wants to go out, when he wants to eat what is on m plate - but the more complex things are harder for me to figure out. I'm glad he doesn't whine with a toy in his mouth. Toys calm him down.

ktrapp profile image

ktrapp 4 years ago from Illinois

This was very interesting. Many times my beagle will try to "bury" the last piece of a bone. She literally will hide it behind cushions and sweep her nose across the couch as if she is covering it up the bone with dirt. Before she finally finds the perfect burying spot though, she will run around with it in her mouth whining. Sometimes she is absolutely frantic, but it has always seemed like instinctual burying behavior to me. Sometimes she not only has the bone in her mouth, but a small toy as well and then "buries" the two together. Thanks for sharing all this information and possible explanations. If only the dogs could tell us themselves.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    alexadry profile image

    Adrienne Janet Farricelli (alexadry)1,687 Followers
    1,247 Articles

    Adrienne Farricelli is a former veterinary hospital assistant and now a certified dog trainer, behavior consultant, and author of dog books.

    Click to Rate This Article