Tankmates for Bettas and Betta Fish in a Community Tank
Betta Tank Mates
If you have a single male Betta fish you may be thinking of finding some tankmates to keep him company, or adding him into a community tank environment so he isn't so lonely.
However, you also know that male Betta fish have a fierce reputation for fighting, and you might fear that any other fish he comes across will be in for a bruising.
So, can you keep any tankmates in your Betta's tank? Or, is there any way he can live in a community tank without issues?
The answer to both questions is maybe. This article intends to dispel some of the myths about Betta fish and give you some practical advice about choosing Betta tankmates.
First: Rest assured, your Betta is not lonely. Bettas are not shoaling fish, nor are they puppies or kittens or people. We tend to attach human emotions to animals like fish, but your Betta has his own concerns in life, and friendship is not among them.
It's important to realize this from the beginning and not make any decisions based on your personal feelings which your Betta surely does not share.
It is also helpful to learn are much as you can about Betta behavior before considering adding anyone to his tank. Much of your success in keeping Betta with other fish will depend on your Betta's temperament. Some Betta are more aggressive, and some more docile. Always have a backup plan like a bowl or small tank in case trouble starts and you have to get him out of there.
The best reaction you can hope for from your Betta in regard to any other fish or critter is tolerance and indifference. The worst, of course, is aggression. It's far better to have a Betta fish in a single-specimen tank than to have him stressed out all the time in a community tank. You need to judge your Betta's interaction with other fish and determine what is right for him.
As responsible fish keepers we want to provide the best care for our Betta fish that we can. That may possibly mean tankmates for your Betta!
Adding Other Fish to Your Betta's Tank
If you already have a Betta fish and you want to add another fish or two to his tank, the first thing you need think about is tank size. I'm going to give you some advice here that you might not like to hear:
If you currently have your Betta fish in a tank smaller than 10 gallons, please do not add any more fish to his tank.
In a tank smaller than 10 gallons he is much better off alone, even if you have the necessary heat and filtration for tropical fish.
Here's a second piece of advice that will help improve your chance of success. You might not like this one either:
It is far better to add a Betta to an established aquarium than to add other creatures in with him in his environment.
In other words, if you plan to have tankmates for your Betta fish you should establish the tank first, then add your Betta. This reduces the possibility of aggression where your Betta may feel like his territory is invaded by other fish.
If you have your Betta in a small tank or bowl and you want tankmates for him, this is the perfect opportunity to upgrade his living situation by putting together a 10-gallon tank where he is the star. But don't add him in there until the tank is cycled, established and the other animals are in residence.
What Fish Can Live With Betta?
If you're planning a 10-gallon tank you need to be very careful about his tankmates. It's a good idea to consider critters instead of fish, as they are much less likely to provoke aggression in your Betta.
You still need to pay very close attention to your Betta's interaction with these other animals, and if things go bad get him, or them, out of there. For reasons known only to him, your Betta may decide he doesn't like the look of any of the critters listed below and constantly be on the attack. Watch closely, and always have a backup plan!
Some critters to consider:
- Apple Snails: These guys come with their own armor. Some Betta fish might try to pick on them, but they can retreat into their shells in defense. One of these guys in a 10-gallon with your Betta is fine. Feed it algae wafers.
- African Dwarf Frogs: They'll float along the top of the water, and like Betta they can get along in a low-flow filtration environment. A couple of them with your Betta makes for an interesting tank. Make sure you have a secure lid on your tank, and watch for Betta picking on them at the surface.
- Ghost Shrimp: These busy little guys are fun to watch, but be careful Betta doesn't think they are lunch. They're scavengers so they'll help keep the tank tidy, and they don't produce a lot of waste. You can have a little school of five of them with your Betta.
Betta in a Community Tank
Betta fish can live in community tanks, under the right circumstances. In fact, under the best of circumstances your Betta will have far better quality of life in a community tank than he would have in a tank by himself.
Because community tanks are usually larger and healthier, your Betta is generally in a better environment than in a small tank. And, even though there is a widespread misconception that Betta prefer small spaces, he will appreciate the extra swimming room.
There are hazards as well. You might think the danger is to your other fish, and if you turn your back Betta will work them over like Rocky punching his way through a meat locker. That can happen for sure.
However, more often it is the Betta who is in danger. Because of his long, flowing fins he can be picked on and nipped at by other fish, even some who seem otherwise docile.
If you intend to keep a Betta fish with other fish you need to realize what you are getting yourself, and him, into. There are a few precautions you can take when stocking your tank to keep the dust-ups to a minimum. Here's a quick checklist:
Betta Tankmate Checklist
- As when establishing a tank where your Betta is the focal point, in a community tank it's a good idea to add Betta to a tank that's already established in order to cut down on territorial issues.
- Make sure there are no fin-nippers in the tank. Barbs and some tetras, even little neons, may find Betta's flowing mane irresistible.
- Beware of other semi-aggressive fish. There are a few different reasons a fish may be considered semi-aggressive. Make sure you understand the temperaments of the other fish in the tank before introducing Betta.
- Avoid other anabantids. Gourami in particular may invoke a strong reaction in your Betta, and vice versa. Juvenile Spotted Climbing Perch present another potential conflict, not only because they are anabantids, but because they will eventually get big enough to eat your Betta!
- Avoid fish that look like him. Fish with long, flowing fins such as Fancy Guppies and Lyre-tail Mollies may be close enough to convince Betta there is another male Betta in the tank.
- Aim for a serene tank. Betta fish don't like fast-moving currents or a lot of action. Despite their reputation as the ninjas of the tropical fish world, they really can't move all that fast and any fish zipping around them may be seen as a threat.
- Make sure there are lots of hiding spots. Even in a single-specimen tank you should make sure your Betta fish has a hiding spot where he can escape from the world. This is even more important in a community tank.
- This should go without saying, but never, ever, put two male Betta fish in the same aquarium together, unless they are separated by a partition.
Can Betta Live With Goldfish?
It may seem like a no-brainer that Betta and Goldfish would make great tankmates. Both are often kept in bowls, after all. But if you take the time to learn more about Goldfish care you’ll see there are some very good reasons that this is a bad idea.
For one thing, Goldfish prefer water temperatures slightly cooler than Bettas. This means one fish or the other will be under stress at all times, and that’s not a humane way to go about fish keeping.
Secondly, Goldfish pollute the water very quickly. They require heavy filtration, and the amount of waste they produce would be stressful for Betta.
Goldfish grow much too large for the typical Betta tank. Where a Betta fish will thrive in a 10-gallon tank, all varieties of Goldfish will quickly outgrow such a setup.
There is also the danger of conflict between the two. While Goldfish are generally docile, they are colorful and often have flowing fins, which has the potential to provoke aggression in a male Betta.
For these reasons, it is not advisable to consider Betta and Goldfish as tankmates. Goldfish are best kept with others of their kind, in a habitant assembled specifically for their needs. Just like Betta, Goldfish do not belong in bowls.
Have a Backup Plan!
Ultimately, your success with Betta tankmates will come down to the temperament of your Betta, and that of your other fish. Even if you follow all of the suggestions in this article there is still a possibility your Betta will not get along in a community tank, or tolerate any other fish or critter in his environment.
Never attempt to keep your Betta with other fish without a backup plan in case it doesn't work out. Have a small tank or bowl handy that you can whisk him into should trouble start.
A little flaring at a passing fish now and then isn't a problem, but if he's constantly looking for a fight he needs to come out for his own good.
If you find your Betta fish tucked into a corner it may be because he's getting picked on and can't find any other hiding spot. Note his fin condition and if it looks like he's been harassed, get him out and into a safer environment immediately.
Try to make the switch to a community tank or tankmate situation during a time period where you can monitor the results for a few days. Don't just wish him luck and toss him in. Make sure you keep a close eye on the situation until you know it is okay.
I hope you choose to keep your Betta fish in a safe environment, whether it's a community tank, a 10-gallon with tankmates, or a single-specimen tank.
The Betta Tank Poll
Have you ever kept a Betta fish in a community tank or with other tankmates?
Read More About Betta Fish
- Betta Facts and FAQ: Betta Fish Care, Behavior and Tank Setup
Learn about Betta Fish care, behavior and tank requirements to make sure your Betta lives a long, healthy life.
- Betta Fish Supplies List
A list of supplies and accessories including everything you need to keep a Betta fish happy and healthy. Give your Betta fish a great home!
- Do Betta Fish Need a Heater and Filter in their Tank?
Find out if you should add a filter and heater to your Betta fish's tank. Learn the true needs of this beautiful tropical fish.
- Betta Fish Tanks: Choose the Best Aquarium for Your Betta
Check out some of the best tanks for your Betta fish and learn how to choose the right size aquarium for a healthy, happy fish.
- Goldfish vs Betta Fish Care and Facts
Get the facts about Goldfish and Betta Fish care and decide which of these popular fish is best for you!
Questions & Answers
Why does my betta tank get cloudy after a few days? I have added biological booster, but that does not seem to help.
Betta tanks can get cloudy for several reasons, including overfeeding, algae blooms and bacterial blooms.
Overfeeding is the easiest to check off the list. Your fish only needs a small pinch of food or about three pellets per day. If you are giving him more than that, you may be starting a cascade that leads to a cloudy tank. After a water change, give him a day of fasting, and then get him back on track with a feeding schedule.
Overfeeding and excess waste can also lead to algae and bacterial blooms. Algae blooms can occur when nitrogen levels from decaying materials rise in your tank, giving the algae a food supply they can thrive on.
Excess sunlight can also cause an algae bloom, so make sure not to place your betta tank in the sun. Algae are like plants, and anything that makes a plant grow will encourage algae growth.
Bacterial blooms often occur after water changes, and again excess waste can be to blame. Healthy bacteria are good, but when their numbers grow rapidly, it can cloud the water. They will balance out over time, and adding biological booster in this situation will only exacerbate the situation.
You can reduce the chances of a bacterial bloom by making sure you don’t remove a huge section of the bacterial population when you perform a water change. Perform a partial water change on tanks with filters (25-30%) and do not remove all of the filter elements at one time if you can help it.
Basic tank maintenance goes a long way when it comes to reducing the chances of cloudy water. Performing regular partial water changes, vacuuming the gravel to remove excess waste, and following a smart feeding schedule are three big things you can do to keep the water clean and healthy for your betta.Helpful 4
I have a betta fish and he is very old. Will he still be aggressive to other fish?
He very well may be. He doesn’t know he’s an old man, and the same instincts he had as a younger betta are likely still there. Just like any other betta, he may get along with tankmates, or he may not.
My concern would be more for his health and safety. As an older fish he is probably a little weaker, and his immune system may not be what it used to be. The danger of putting a betta with other fish is only partially about him attacking the other fish. There is also a chance they could bully him or pick at his fins. For any betta that would be incredibly stressful, but for an older fish it could be fatal.
Why not give him his own beautiful 5-gallon tank and let him live out his final days in peace? Curmudgeonly old betta fish probably don’t appreciate annoying young guppies zipping around them. Less stress for him, and he might even live longer.